Jeremy follows an orange cat called Aristotle to a little room in the mysterious Enchanted Theater, where he meets the owner, Mr. Magnus. The theater is cursed with bad luck, the audiences don't come any more, and the actors have quit. The only clue is a lightening bolt in the shape of the letter Z, a sign from Zeus, the king of the ancient Greek gods! With the guidance of Mr. Magnus and the Enchanted Theater Rule Book, Jeremy and Aristotle travel back in time to Mount Olympus to meet Zeus and find out why he is punishing Mr. Magnus and his theater. Along the way, they encounter a fiery giant, a deer with a silver horn, angry gods, and some lively nymphs. To add to their troubles, Jeremy has no idea how to get home!